College Media Network - Search the largest news resource for college students by college students

America's Next Top Model features hot tranny mess

By Caitlyn Scott

Print this article

Published: Tuesday, August 26, 2008

Updated: Tuesday, August 26, 2008

Ladies and gentleman, the inevitable has happened — Tyra Banks has lost her freaking mind.

No, I’m not talking about the horrendous crimped hairstyle she recently wore to celebrate Vogue Italia’s first all-black model issue.

I’m not even referencing the recent reports that she kept an audience for her talk show waiting for two hours while she gabbed with stagehands around the snack table backstage.

I’m talking about Isis, Banks’ newest headline-snagging protégé.

Fourteen contestants are taking part in Cycle 11 of “America’s Next Top Model,” but only one of those 14 has the distinction of being born a man.

The 22-year-old aspiring model and Maryland native told Us Weekly that she is a woman who was born a male.

Now, I understand everyone is different — and transgendered persons have just as much right to be America’s next top model as anyone else.

But I personally find it a little hard to believe that Isis is more qualified to strut her stuff down the runway than the thousands of actual women she beat out for the part — including a bevy of Baton Rouge beauties when auditions were held in our fair city.

Which leads me to my next question — Is Isis pre-op or post-op?

She is tall, thin and leggy with boyish good looks that could lead to either conclusion.

Perhaps this is the final push in the campaign started by Twiggy in the 1960s and revived by Kate Moss in the 1990s of having runway models with the figures of 13-year-old boys.

Instead of having high-strung cocaine addicts who puke after meals as role models, young girls can idolize the bodies of modern- day eunuchs.

Perhaps Isis’ inherent testosterone will make her less of a cat-fighting attention whore than the other divas in training.

If Banks, the CW and co. want something to talk about, why not just allow men to participate in the show? Then Isis could stand and deliver without the surgery.

Do men want to be snipped at by noted fashion photographer Nigel Barker and runway diva extraordinaire Miss J. Alexander so badly that they’ll go to excruciating lengths to reach their goal? Are they aching for face time with Paulina Porizkova so hard that they’re willing to castrate themselves?

I wonder how Isis’ past will influence her performance on the show.

The ANTM judges have always expressed their love of androgyny in contestants like Cycle 5’s Kim. But what about Kim’s fellow castmate Coryn, who was frequently chastised for being too masculine?

I wonder if such comments directed at Isis would be considered offensive.

If this was a true attempt to be open-minded and progressive, I would applaud the ANTM team. But I call a spade a spade, and shameless plays for ratings make me reach for my Daily Reveille-issued shovel.

Plus-sized models are old news. We’ve seen scores of confrontational contestants. We’ve had race issues out the wazoo. There was even a lesbian hook up in Cycle 5. Now we’ve reached the final frontier of edgy reality TV.

Can a woman — born a man, but now a woman — make it as a top model?

This must herald the final chapter of “America’s Next Top Model.” How do they top this? Lizard people?

ANTM has a rich and diverse history of capitalizing on the differences of one girl each season.

Cycle 3 winner Eva was short – for a model.

Cycle 5 contestant Kim was a lesbian and Cycle 10 winner Whitney was plus sized.

They even had Heather — a contestant with Asperger’s Syndrome — on Cycle 9.

Banks recaps the chosen sob story at the front of every episode in an effort to strengthen the contestant’s emotional chokehold on the audience.

And honestly, if Isis is cool with being exploited who am I to contradict her? I’m sure this is the big throbbing break she’s been waiting for all her young life.

Gay and Lesbian Alliance Against Defamation president Neil Giuliano told Us Weekly this is “an unprecedented opportunity for a community that is underrepresented on television.”

I have to respectfully disagree with Mr. Giuliano.

Is he completely disregarding the character of Mrs. Garrison on South Park?

Besides, no one encompasses the phrase “hot tranny mess” better than Tyra Banks — and I see her on TV every day.



----
contact Caitlyn Scott at cscott@reveille.com

Comments

32 comments
Jim
Fri Jan 9 2009 04:19
This world is getting sicker by the minute. Nuff said.
Your name
Sun Sep 21 2008 13:25
next top model cyle 5
Kaitlin SNOT hehheh
Tue Sep 9 2008 19:51
Wait, SHOCKER! The Daily Reveille has some completely fucking ignorant (and offensive) thing to publish the first week of school! Hmmm...I wonder if perhaps it's a gimmick to get more readers. I guess we'll never know.
And all you other detractors should probably get educated about the subject you write about before you spout your garbage on message boards the public can see.
Your name
Tue Sep 9 2008 03:44
lesbian lizard people would be cooler - watching some hot chick reptiles get funky...
Ariahn
Mon Sep 8 2008 21:03
I totally agree with Jordan Clide. i cant imagine those balls popping out with boobs on top. eww
Jordan Clide (girl)
Mon Sep 8 2008 21:01
I don't think she is going to win,oh wait I mean I know HE is not going to win .Just think about it it's crazy I know theres nothing wrong with being who you are but serousiously whats up with that just picture him/her on the cover of victorias secret or covergirl can you picture that I can and it's HIDIOUS I'm sorry isis you night be good but you have no chance eww I'm still blind from that thought in my head think about them balls I KNOW RIGHT ! who knows, maybe he got them chopped off.
Ariahn
Mon Sep 8 2008 20:53
Wow, i think tyra has lost her mind. I dont think isis will win. Sorry to chez crisden, but she wont win. I mean HE. It's a guy. and yea maybe he is good-looking for a transgender, but not enough to be top model. its for women. Isis is never going to be a model. sorry.
chez crisden
Mon Sep 8 2008 14:56
this whole situtation is going to change history; oh wait, it did 9/3/08 8pm.

with girls--some of them making hideous comments about isis behind her back, as well as her voting photo shoot; isis is working it.

SHE JUST MIGHT BE THE WINNER.
so other ladies of cycle 11, pack your bags and go home, isis is the winner.

Jonny
Sat Sep 6 2008 16:40
So, let me get this straight... You're criticizing Tyra banks for using Isis' transgender status to sensationalize the show, right? Much in the same way you're using this non-story to sensationalize your article. Nice work.

BTW-If someone is speaking for God, they should at least try to spell correctly. If I were speaking for the president, I'd TRIPLE-CHECK what I wrote...and I don't even like him! I would think the standard is a little higher for speaking for the divine creator of everything.

ANTMfan
Fri Sep 5 2008 15:03
he's pre-op.
Jesus H. Christ
Thu Sep 4 2008 19:57
You know, this whole thing about people hating Transexuals, perhaps because God didn't intend them to exist or maybe because they don't think they fit in with the scheme of things, is unadulterated bull. God has no less love for transexuals than he does for anyone else. Maybe trying to play God is against His designs, but this is why He gave man free will. So they can do what they want. Let them live their lives, it's not like they're asking you to do the same thing. Let it be.
Megan
Thu Sep 4 2008 15:00
lol at the "god" comments up there. Bigot much?
YESISAIDIT
Thu Sep 4 2008 11:07
U scientogoly ppl are sick....God does not make mistakes when he create flat out. IF GOD AMDE U TO BE A MAN U ARE JUST THAT...THERE IS NOT SCIENCE OR LOGIC IN THIS WORLD THAT CAN CHANGE WHAT GOD PERMANATELY SHAPPED. WHO IS ANY MAN IN THIS WORLD TO GO AGAINST GOD??
AJ
Wed Sep 3 2008 17:07
This article, commentary, or whatever you want to call it is written in such an obnoxious and hateful tone it's ridiculous. It's obvious you do not understand the true nature of trans-gendered people by the ridiculous things you've stated above.
Emily
Tue Sep 2 2008 16:06
all the other top fashion models have a manly or androgenous look to them. What's the difference? Maybe we should just be parading drag queens down the catwalk.
Emily
Tue Sep 2 2008 15:16
all the other top fashion models have a manly or androgenous look to them. What's the difference? Maybe we should just be parading drag queens down the catwalk.
Bridget
Mon Sep 1 2008 09:46
I just tried to post a comment, and it didn't go through, apparently, so I'll try one more time. I don't think it is fair for Isis to be on, because she was on the show in cycle 10! She was a "background" model in the girl's homeless photo shoot, and they even show her name, like they are promoting her already or something. Since she's already affiliated with the show, it just doesn't seem fair at all.
Bridget
Mon Sep 1 2008 09:41
I somehow don't think it is fair for Isis to be on, because she was on the show in cycle 10, where she was a "background" model in the girl's homeless photo shoot. So evidently she's been affiliated with the show already. SO NOT FAIR!
Yasmine
Sun Aug 31 2008 20:48
i'm a mtf transgender, and i as well found this offensive. they did not take her in for the sole purpose of ratings. they took her in because she IS a woman, and she is a good model. who do you think you are saying that isis shouldn't be taken seriously because you don't think she is an "actual woman." the show has been going on for 10 cycles, it's only natural that more diverse and unique new faces will be apart of the next upcoming cycle. FYI, kim stolz was not the only lesbian put on the show. in the first season, ebony haith was apart of the cast, and she was a lesbian. the point is, girls of all different ethnic backgrounds, sexual orientations, body types, and so on have been on the show. why is this all of a sudden such a controversy?
Matthew
Sat Aug 30 2008 13:44
Dacia,

I don't believe that anyone here has suggested that Caitlyn Scott is not allowed to voice an opinion. Please refrain from making unfounded accusations such as that. The general theme of the objections to this article has been that her opinion is based on faulty and frankly offensive premises. (The comparison of transgender women to "lizard people," for example, is dehumanizing and rude. There is no excuse for that.) Of course she has the right to say whatever she wishes, and the Reveille has the right to print it, but nobody has the Constitutional right to be free from criticism.







log out