The Daily Reveille

Comparing different majors, there is no comparison

By Marie-Therese Yokum

Columnist

Published: Sunday, February 5, 2012

Updated: Thursday, February 9, 2012

majors

LACYE BEAUREGARD / The Daily Reveille

Everyone usually attends college for the same group of reasons: to enhance learning on a subject you favor, to experience the stereotyped life of parties and drinking, to get paid more than those who don't attend or because it's what everyone else is doing.

Just like in any environment, biases based on competition emerge.

A select group of majors, such as engineering, science and pre-med, are known for believing that they have harder tests, grading scales, courses and material to learn. Comparing grade point averages between majors isn't possible, however, because of the heavier burdens they have to endure.

Engineering majors alone will take an average of 128 to 132 hours and are required to take calculus, physics and chemistry their first semester on campus. They are also the only college at the University with a complex flow chart outlining required courses and prerequisites needed.

Majors that don't appear as complex from their titles — such as kinesiology, studio art or communication studies — receive the stereotype that getting a major in said fields is easy.

Studio art freshman Patrick Lebas agreed.

"People think we color in books and draw pretty pictures," Lebas said. "We take foundation classes and go through materials before getting to actually produce anything."

By the time we get into college, everyone should know that prejudging anything is a mistake.

To claim certain majors are harder than others is like saying hockey is less intense than football. Both require specialized training and teamwork — how can you say that one is harder than the other?

I was under the crazy impression that everyone understood why students are given the opportunity to select their own major in college: by making the decision to major in a field of our choice, the decision to achieve its requirements is implied.

"It's what interests me. It's difficult, but not overwhelming," said animal science junior Keaton Lea.

Misconceptions about majors are too easy to make. When the average person on campus hears kinesiology, he or she usually associates the major with being easy or even one undeclared majors pick for the time being.

Kinesiology junior Brittney Hampton explained that her curriculum has many different concentrations, with most students interested in physical therapy looking at grad school, where a 3.7 grade point average is the minimum. Graduate Record Examination scores and experience in the field are also considered.

"We take chemistry, anatomy and conditioning classes where not everyone is easy to work with," Hampton said.

After discussing the topic of stigmas with students on campus, I found that most acknowledge majors like engineering are harder because of the courses required within a semester.

I also concluded that other majors even out in challenge when it comes to other aspects like networking, portfolios and internship/experience — something that future employers look at much more intensely in majors relating to communication or art.

"The hours spent studying and completing homework are equal to the amount of time we spend with paintings and graphic design," said studio art senior Justin Reed.

I always knew there was a reason that the design buildings were kept open practically 24 hours.

How we are taught the information needed to excel in the field of our choice is always going to be different. No need to claim that apples work harder than oranges — something that provides just as many benefits to society and is a fruit all the same.

"There will always be stigmas with anyone's major, but if you're passionate, that shouldn't matter," communication studies sophomore Bridget Bailey said.

At the end of the day, hopefully the lesson learned is that comparing majors with varying requirements is impossible because the scales are not the same. Pursuing any major in college will involve studying, while success in any field will require practice regardless.

Marie-Therese Yokum is a 19-year-old mass communication and finance sophomore from Lafayette. Follow her on Twitter @TDR_myokum.

 

----

Contact Marie-Therese Yokum at myokum@lsureveille.com

Comments

7 comments
Stacey Halphen, LSU Career Services
Fri Feb 17 2012 10:09
The first comment states, " If you go to LSU Career Services and ask for a "What Can I do With This Degree?" sheet on Communication Studies, they don't have one! True story! " This statement is incorrect. In the resources section of our Career Decision Making webpage (http://careercenter.lsu.edu/choose-a-major) you can find a link to What Can I do with This Degree? Here you will find a resource specifically for Communication Studies majors (http://whatcanidowiththismajor.com/major/communication-studies/).
Anonymous
Thu Feb 9 2012 23:35
I agree with Lily. I can respect the work that many majors put into their studies, however, hard work such as ditch digging doesn't compare to top notch academic research. Last time I checked no one was paying decent money to consult on how people communicate. If you go to LSU Career Services and ask for a "What Can I do With This Degree?" sheet on Communication Studies, they don't have one! True story! Lastly, if this is indeed the case, why do members of the Communication Studies Department feel the need to justify their existence?
Anonymous
Wed Feb 8 2012 23:05
There is one thing you engineers are forgetting, ARCHITECTS have to go through a rigorous process also before we are able to become fully licensed. Even though it is a rigorous process, I continue it because I feel a love and a passion for my major. My core studio classes are no where like a Physics or English class, but I can't step into one those classes and expect it to be a walk in the park. I prefer to taking a core studio class over an Physics or English class any day. No major comes easy, EVERYBODY has to work to get to their career goal they want in life. You Engineering majors should watch what you say about other majors because you all will be working along side of these so called "easy majors" and some of these so called "easy major" could be the person who determines whether or not you get a job or an internship at an engineer firm.
Anonymous
Wed Feb 8 2012 10:37
I like how she didn't ask any engineering majors anything. "Hmm, I'll just make these massive assumptions about everything with absolutely no evidence!" If there is one thing engineering colleges push, it's internships and work experience.

The only major with as much work as STEM (Science, Tech, Engineering, Math) majors is education. There is no possible way to hold a job with as much classroom( elementary or secondary) time as they are expected to do, for free of course. That's not even counting the semester of actual teaching they do before graduation, that they actually have to pay for (10 credits at my uni.)

Anonymous
Wed Feb 8 2012 04:01
There is so much wrong here it just blows my mind. Engineering students have to get internships and network just as anyone else and I would go as so far to say for some engineering majors the race to get an internship is much more competitive then most non-engineering majors. There's a reason that every engineer I know considers LSA classes a break from real school. Not to mention that those basic physics classes mentioned are just that: basic. I would wager that anyone who can graduate with a degree is smart enough to understand basic physics but I would love to see a communication major try to explain to me the various assumptions made in Linear Wave Theory or explain the derivation of the Naiver-Stokes equations or even try a hand a Quantum Mechanics and the Schrödinger equations. Yeah, not every major is created equal.
Lily
Tue Feb 7 2012 23:11
Engineering majors ALSO need to get internships and experience, Anonymous. Sorry, but this article didn't convince me that my communications major friends work as hard on their academics as my engineering major friends. Maybe it's a lot of "work" by their standards, but the level of critical thinking and difficulty and skill mastery that goes into engineering is way more time consuming and mentally taxing.
Anonymous
Tue Feb 7 2012 12:45
This is a really good article! Let people know that everything isn't just as it seems on the surface, and that communicaton major have to get internships, portfolios and experience to excel in our field to get a certain job just like those engineering majors have to take physics 5 times.
View full site