College Media Network - Search the largest news resource for college students by college students Jobs and internships for students -

Lombardi suggests tuition raise, TOPS reform

By Kyle Bove

Senior Staff Writer

Print this article

Published: Monday, October 26, 2009

Updated: Tuesday, October 27, 2009

LSU System President John Lombardi presented his blueprint for dealing with higher education budget cuts to the Louisiana Postsecondary Education Review Commission on Monday and left members with a string of questions.

In a prepared address, Lombardi said college management boards like the LSU Board of Supervisors should have the authority to control tuition and fee increases for colleges, rather than leaving it to the Legislature exclusively.

The state is looking at a budget cut of about $150 million during the next fiscal year for its public colleges and universities, but Lombardi said many states are going through similar hardships and have found ways to cope.

“Every state that has faced these problems has found it necessary to shift more of the cost of higher education to students and their parents,” he said.

Lombardi’s suggested plan also includes an overhaul of the TOPS program.

The scholarship – which covers full tuition at the University using state dollars for students who meet ACT and GPA requirements – should be changed to a one-time merit award of $2,000.

The leftover money set aside for TOPS should be used along with Go-Grant funding to establish a stronger need-based financial aid program, Lombardi said.

“It is abundantly clear that TOPS is a program that supports many students who have no demonstrated financial need, and it inadequately supports other talented students with a high need,” Lombardi said.

According to data collected by the Louisiana Office of Student Financial Assistance, 38 percent of TOPS recipients come from families with incomes of more than $100,000 per year.

“You have the money to pay it – pay it,” Lombardi told Commission member Tony Clayton, who is on the Board of Supervisors for the Southern University System.

Clayton told Lombardi he has spent upward of $200,000 putting his kids through private schools so they could have the best chance at earning the TOPS scholarship.

Lombardi argued these families can afford to spend more money on their children’s education all the way through college as well.

“We have to think differently about the TOPS program,” Lombardi said. “TOPS is not funding higher education — it’s funding individuals.”

Many argue the TOPS program keeps students in the state, but Lombardi said the high cost of out-of-state tuition and fees is enough to keep students in Louisiana.

Lombardi said raising tuition and fees and reconfiguring TOPS will allow the LSU System — especially LSU-Baton Rouge, the state’s flagship institution – to be nationally competitive.

Creating a $30 million flagship fund would also help the University, Lombardi said. Chancellor Michael Martin introduced the idea at a Faculty Senate-sponsored meeting recently, and it would charge students an extra $500 a semester to attend the University.

Lombardi said the fund would enable the University to perform at nationally competitive levels.

Student Government President Stuart Watkins and members of his executive staff attended the meeting.

“If [the flagship fee] is going to preserve the academic core of the University, I think it’s a sacrifice the students will have to make to preserve the quality of education at LSU,” Watkins said.

Lombardi compared academics at the University to its athletic program several times throughout his address. He said the University would be much better if Martin could run the school like the Tiger Athletic Foundation runs LSU Athletics.

All funding for LSU Athletics is private.

Commission member and former University chancellor James Wharton expressed his views about athletics and the University during the question-and-answer segment of his address.

“The fact of the matter is that [LSU athletics] is national entertainment,” he said.

But Wharton said solving the issue of funding and budget cuts is more complicated than just raising tuition.

“Saying the campus could change tuition to whatever it wants is misleading,” Wharton said.
The Commission is charged with evaluating higher education in the state and reporting back to the Legislature in the spring. Its report is due to the Board of Regents by Feb. 12.




- - - -
Contact Kyle Bove at kbove@lsureveille.com

Recommended: Articles that may interest you

7 comments

Student
Wed Nov 18 2009 22:51
Why didn't the talented students who needed the financial aid get it based on merit?
Your name
Fri Nov 6 2009 15:57
Really what I see happening is that the University got state budget cuts and is expecting more so Lombardi is trying to just get that money back by making the students not only pay more in tuition but also start paying for their tuition with almost no scholarships available to them. TOPS is one of the very few ACADEMIC based programs left in Louisiana and honestly that is the only reason I went to school here. My family may be able to pay for my tuition but they won't, it is a very clear rule for me that I have to pay for myself after high school. Thus, if TOPS didn't exist or were changed to a simple 1-time stipend and tuition were raised I would definitely leave. I agree that LSU needs money to preserve it's 'academic core' but the way to do it is not to attack the students because the University, as the State University, should be accessible to everyone in the state, not just those who fit into a certain ethnic or need-based class. If these TOPS reforms go through, I guarantee LSU will lose many of their best students who qualify for great scholarships elsewhere. Like the previous commenter said, great thinking there.
correct
Thu Oct 29 2009 09:12
Hey I have this crazy idea, make your kid work his way through college like I and many others have. Since when do we whine about every little thing the government won't give us. Your kid now has the chance to grow some hair on his back and become an adult while getting a great education. Be thankful instead of lowering yourself. That's my opinion.
Your name
Tue Oct 27 2009 22:38
When tuition increases, TOPS increases. When TOPS increases, that eats into state appropriations and when the economy is slow and cuts need to be made higher education and health care are the top two. Then higher education raises its tuition or fees and as a result TOPS continues to grow and grow because tuition grows and TOPS continues to eat into the state budget.
Student
Tue Oct 27 2009 18:23
I'm not saying the state should pay for tuition, but if the state is going to have a program like TOPS, whose goal is to keep students in Louisiana, then the program should do its' job and try to keep all students in Louisiana, not based on income. Why should half the students take the burden of the entire student body even though both halves have worked equally hard?
Your name
Tue Oct 27 2009 14:56
Why should the state pay for you to go to school?
Student
Tue Oct 27 2009 13:31
Once again Lombardi is fighting to hurt the average student at LSU. TOPS is a merit based program, not a need based program and that is the way it should remain. There are many other need based programs through FASFA and other private entities as well as through the office of financial aid. The income of a family of a student receiving TOPS should be irrelevant because it is based on achievement and focused at keeping the deserving in the state-- rich or poor. If LSU continues to raise tuition and reduce TOPS and rely on the rich to support the school and give the lesser more financial need, the enrollment and quality of this school will plummet. He claims families have enough to so they should "pay it", but then believes these same upper class families will not stay in state because out of state fees are high. Yet, if these families have so much money then paying out of state fees will be no problem. High achieving students will move to bigger and better schools outside of the state in which merit based scholarships are still abundant and LSU will be left with a decreased tuition and in a much more severe budget crisis because the majority of students who choose to stay at LSU will be the ones receiving a much high percentage of aid and unable to pay for any increases. Great thinking Lombardi, great thinking.






log out