Top College News Subscribe to the Newsletter

My Opinion: Vick haters should heed ‘The Wire’s’ example

Sports Columnist

Published: Saturday, August 29, 2009

Updated: Sunday, August 30, 2009 21:08

michael_vick_ap

FILE PHOTO / The Associated Press

Eagles quarterback Michael Vick made a comeback to the NFL after 23 months in jail.

Philadelphia Eagles quarterback Michael Vick's  return to the NFL has been a long and winding road.


The man seems to breed contempt and condemnation from the public for his attempt to play the game, despite his athletic ability, which is frankly quite superb.


But perhaps people should look to an example set forth by characters in the HBO series "The Wire."


In the opening scene of the series' first episode, the viewers see a man, Omar "Snot Boogie" Betts, lying dead in the streets of Baltimore.


Apparently, Betts was murdered because he had a habit of playing in and subsequently robbing dice games throughout the neighborhood.


Usually, according to a witness of the crime, Betts was simply beaten up for his transgressions.


The whole situation puzzled homicide detective Jimmy McNulty, and he wondered aloud why Betts was allowed to continue to join dice games.


"If every time Snot Boogie would grab the money and run away, why'd you even let him in the game?" he asked the witness.

To which the witness simply   replied: "Got to. It's America, man."


This is an awfully simplistic reason to want Vick back on the field, but it's just as valid of a reason as those who would want to deny him.


America is the land of second chances, and those who would seek to deny Vick his chance at redemption are hypocritical at best and idiots at worst.


After all, there are players in the NFL who've committed crimes against other humans, yet we as people don't seem to mind them getting their lives back on track and playing on Sundays.


There's no doubt Vick has had his fair share of off-the-field problems.


He was once punished by the NFL for making an obscene gesture to the crowd at a Falcons game following a defeat by the Saints in 2006.


He's gotten into trouble a couple of times in airports too. Once he was caught with a water bottle with a secret compartment that many speculated held drugs.

Another time, while he and some of his associates were going through a security checkpoint in an airport in Atlanta, one of his associates was seen stealing a watch.


But, few things are seen as more morally reprehensible than his biggest misstep.


After a federal investigation, charges were filed against Vick for his involvement with a dog fighting ring.


Vick was accused of financing the ring that sometimes held fights at his home in Virginia, participating in dog fights, executing dogs and handling the illegal gambling money.


He eventually plead guilty to "Conspiracy to Travel in Interstate Commerce in Aid of Unlawful Activities and to Sponsor a Dog in an Animal Fighting Venture" and was sentenced to 23 months in a federal prison in Leavenworth, Kan.


Dog fighting is wrong — there's no doubt about it. But nearly two years in a federal penitentiary is sufficient enough punishment for a crime that only carries a six-month sentence in some states.

Animal rights groups have been on Vick's case since the charges have been filed, and many requested his permanent ban from the NFL — which is just absurd.


Vick paid his penance by serving his prison term, and at this point he's just trying to get his life back on track.


He's being mentored by one of the greats in the coaching profession, Tony Dungy, and by many accounts has turned his life around.


He's trying to work with animal rights groups, get his finances in order and spend time with his family.


He doesn't need PETA on his case claiming his signing has "disappointed millions of decent football fans," and refusing to work with him while implying that Vick may be a psychopath.


This is America, man — the country where everybody should get a second chance.

Follow Johanathan Brooks on Twitter @TDR_jbrooks.

----
Contact Johanathan Brooks at jbrooks@lsureveille.com
 

Recommended: Articles that may interest you

15 comments

Some One
Fri Sep 4 2009 00:10
The public record of Michael Vick's involvement in the Bad Newz Kennels dog fighting ring speaks loudly of a man not only devoid of the capacity for empathy, but also possessed of a lust of suffering and abuse that ranks him alongside the most sadistic of our times. That Michael Vick served out the latter part of a suspiciously lenient sentence in home confinement makes fills me far more with contempt for the obvious classism that plays itself out in courtrooms across this country than it does any notion that Michael Vick has relieved himself of any moral debt for the utter depravity of his actions, which were both gruesome and numerous. One would hope that the better part of Michael Vick's moral deficit would be payed back over a life of remorse, nightmares, broken relationships, and widely reciprocated ill-will, but unfortunately, the hope for any of that is lost in light of the heartless heart of the true psychopath. Michael Vick. Jersey anyone?
John Salard
Thu Sep 3 2009 20:12
If you mistreat an animal, you will mistreat a child !!!!!!!!!!!!
Glenn Salard
Wed Sep 2 2009 21:22
QUOTE: Vick paid his penance by serving his prison term, and at this point he’s just trying to get his life back on track.
REPLY: The above statement says it as it SHOULD be in America. I disagree with you on most issues, but not this one. I know I may garner some grief on this subject. He has paid for his crime. If others think it was not enough time, then I suggest that you petition the lawmakers for a change in the sentencing guidlines, and/or hold accountable those that give such short sentences for a crime such as he commited. I personally do not think he spent enough time in jail. I also do not think that he should be kept from playing football.
Opinions are like, well, you know. It's just my opinion.
Nick
Wed Sep 2 2009 11:52
If Vick had been, say, been bothered by a dog and over reacted by brutally killing the dog, then I'd say he deserved a 2nd chance after taking responsibility for his overreaction. However, he spent 6 years entertaining himself by having dogs bite each other to death and doing many other sadistic things to animals. He also engaged in similar activities for many years before he got rich enough to finance a large scale, dog fighting operation. So the concept of "2nd chance" doesn't really apply. He had about 12 years and thousands of chances to think "Gee, I'm putting these animals thru agony maybe I should do something else." To say that Vick deserves a 2nd chance just indicates that one doesn't think that torturing and killing animals for fun is a big deal. For example, one doesn't contend that a serial killer deserves a 2nd chance.
susan cotton
Tue Sep 1 2009 19:49
Michael Vick and his friends tortured and killed animals for fun. He could afford to do anything that he wanted to do to for fun. What he wanted to do was to beat dogs and hang dogs and electrocute dogs with jumper cables. It was his hobby. He and his friends enjoyed afternoons, attaching jumper cables to the ears of beaten dogs, tossing them in pools of water and watching them fight for their last breaths. That's just how they are. That's what they like. And apparently so do lots of other people.

Look at it this way. We animal nuts are just adding a little spice to your game. I mean, dogs are easy, right? Put ‘em on a short chain, bash ‘em over the head with a baseball bat, knock out their teeth and voila, hours of fun! It’s so easy. Because the animals cannot speak in their own defense.
But we can speak in their defence. And we will, so get used to it.

So what...Hines Ward eats dogs
Mon Aug 31 2009 16:48
To the person who is done with the NFL: So long, two new fans were just born in the time it took you to make up your mind. My only problem with Vick is that he screwed the dirty birds to sign with the arlen spector birds.
Your name
Mon Aug 31 2009 16:10
Since the original post referenced "The Wire," watchers will no doubt recall that the show itself tackled -- albeit tangentially -- the subculture of dogfighting in a few episodes, through the character of Cheese. Assuming Johnathan doesn't want people to follow "The Wire's" example as relates to *that* character, per se. :)
huston
Mon Aug 31 2009 12:11
good column my man. i'm right with you. i mean, stallworth killed a man just a few months ago and is already out of prison. JR smith also killed a man after running through a stop sign and he was only sentenced to 90 days ( which ended up being suspended in lieu of 500 hours of COMMUNITY SERVICE. what a joke. guess animals are more important than people nowadays...
Mark
Mon Aug 31 2009 11:46
People make bad decisions everyday. Noone is perfect and if they are able to show remorce than I believe they should be given a second chance. The ctime he paid for doing the crime he committed is sufficient enough. He is willing to work with the Humane Society to prevent other occurences of the same crime he committed. Everyone is different and even though i'm an animal lover I am willing to give Michael Vick a second chance. Than again who are we to decide if he deserves a second chance or not? God will forgive him, whats more pwerful than that?! If you were in his shoes you would want a second chance as well. There are too many hypocrites in this world, just shut up and let the man make a chance to prove to you hes a changed man. I believe in him!
Zuander
Mon Aug 31 2009 10:31
Vick has been a problem child in the NFL since he started playing. His 'biggest mistep', fighting dogs and killing them when they didn't perform well, is just the latest in a string of established bad behavior. I didn't see anything in the 60 Minutes interview to suggest that he had 'turned his life around'. Second chances and redemption are earned by word and deed, and Vick just ain't there yet.

It's a shame that the NFL keeps employing these miscreants...Vick is just another in a long line of them in the NFL. I'm sick of it and it's why I won't watch it anymore or attend any games. His signing just after he was released from prison before he could demonstrate that he had indeed turned his life around did disappoint this decent football fan.

Your name
Mon Aug 31 2009 10:21
What does being an animal lover have to do with anything. You cannot persecute a man forever for a wrong doing, especially when he has been punished, well over the crime. People rape, murder, steal and they seem to be forgiven so easily, but commit a crime involving an animal.................is a death sentence to you people. I love dogs and have had one always. This story has nothing to do with being an animal lover, but it has more to do with mans condemming others to make themselves feel better. GET OFF YOUR HIGH HORSE!
Eb
Mon Aug 31 2009 09:49
I am an animal lover and I think what he did was heinous but like the author said, the man spent 2 years of his life behind a federal prison...we should just lay off him. Nobody saying anything about Dante Stallworth who killed a man while he was drunk and he only served 24 days in a county jail...so what message are we really sending; that America is willing to put the value of a dog's life over the value's of a man....besides the dogs that everybody is talking about, most of them have been adopted out and Michael Vick is paying for them...Let it go please.
Fleur de lis
Mon Aug 31 2009 08:34
Vick has been a problem child in the NFL since he started playing. His 'biggest mistep', fighting dogs and killing them when they didn't perform well, is just the latest in a string of established bad behavior. I didn't see anything in the 60 Minutes interview to suggest that he had 'turned his life around'. Second chances and redemption are earned by word and deed, and Vick just ain't there yet.

It's a shame that the NFL keeps employing these miscreants...Vick is just another in a long line of them in the NFL. I'm sick of it and it's why I won't watch it anymore or attend any games. His signing just after he was released from prison before he could demonstrate that he had indeed turned his life around did disappoint this decent football fan.

Fred
Mon Aug 31 2009 05:26
Forget PETA and the other animal zealots. let them whine while watching Animal Planet on Gameday. Those nuts arent the demographic the NFL is for anyway.
Your name
Mon Aug 31 2009 01:19
Looks like you are not a animal lover so what would you care.






log out